Ken Kubo
Sixth Sunday after Trinity · July 27, 2025
Scripture: Matthew 5:20


JESUS said unto his disciples, Except your righteousness shall exceed the righteousness of the scribes and Pharisees, ye shall in no case enter into the kingdom of heaven. (St. Matt. 5:20)

Some of you may have heard (or even used) the term “Philadelphia Lawyer.” While it is sometimes used in modern slang to refer to someone who can argue technicalities, in its original 18th century use, it was a term of great respect. Philadelphia lawyers had the reputation of being the most knowledgeable and skilled in the colonies. “This would puzzle a Philadelphia lawyer” was used to describe problems particularly difficult to solve. A Philadelphia Lawyer was one with a deep knowledge of the law and judicial precedents.

During the time of our Lord’s earthly ministry, there were two groups noted for these. The Sadducees were scholars of the law and took a literal interpretation of the written Torah; legal fundamentalists of the time. The Pharisees emphasized both the written Law as well as oral traditions. They are frequently mentioned in one breath in Scripture as being adversarial to our Lord and His followers. Historically, they were often in conflict, mostly because the Sadducees did not acknowledge the oral traditions, including belief in an afterlife. They did both collaborate with the Roman government to maintain order among the Jewish people, so they put aside their differences when a new Messiah arose to threaten that order. A common enemy can make strange bedfellows. Our Lord gave them their due, though, by acknowledging that they studied and knew the Law and kept it. This is “the righteousness of the scribes and Pharisees.” Our Lord set this as a baseline and taught his disciples that they had to do better.

Keep in mind that our Lord honored the Law and Covenant of God with the Jews. “Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled.” (St. Matt. 5:18) [NB, the “jot” is the smallest letter in the Hebrew alphabet, a “tittle” is a small tick on some letters, like a serif] He came to complete and fulfill the Law. As anyone who has watched a procedural crime drama knows, there is the letter of the law and the spirit, and the difference between them makes for a good episode. When I asked my new best AI friend about this I was informed that the letter of the law focuses on the precise wording of the law without context or intent and emphasized strict (rigid, inflexible) compliance with the written text. Sounds a lot like our Sadducees and Pharisees. The spirit of the law, on the other hand, focuses on the underlying purpose and intent of the law, emphasizing fairness and justice. That’s a lot harder to work with because it’s less tangible. The written word is, after all, written down. It’s by definition black and white. But as one of Terry Pratchett’s characters stated, “TAKE THE UNIVERSE AND GRIND IT DOWN TO THE FINEST POWDER AND SIEVE IT THROUGH THE FINEST SIEVE AND THEN SHOW ME ONE ATOM OF JUSTICE, ONE MOLECULE OF MERCY.” (Hogfather) Yet we know that justice and mercy exist, sometimes only when we see their absence. Those of us who are parents know that we never had to teach our children to say “that’s not fair!” – one day, that just out of their mouths much to our chagrin. Our Lord is asking is that we use that understanding when we both comply with and enforce the Law. This is a big ask. As a challenge, something you might try is taking one of the “thou shalt not” Commandments and rephrase it as something you would do. “Thou shalt not steal” might become “I will respect other people’s property”.

Yet thou her child, whose head is crowned with flame,
Still wilt not hear thine inner God proclaim,
“Turn back, O man, forswear thy foolish ways.”
– Clifford Bax, 1919

Whatever our learning, our earthly position, our acknowledged subject matter expertise, we can fail because of information we don’t have, assumptions that are invalid, or just not listening to other points of view. This in no way makes us bad people! But for our spiritual course, we do best when we keep an ear out for that niggling, questioning, “are you sure about this?” coming from the depths of our soul. When the Lord reached out to the Prophet Elijah, there was a windstorm and an earthquake and a fire – the Lord showing Elijah a bad day in California to get his attention. God was not in those (Earth, Wind, and Fire was just the pretty good warmup band). God was a small, quiet voice, just a whisper but clear (I Kings 19). We don’t have to be prophets to listen as he did. The problem is that there is so much noise in our world, both externally and internally, that quietness is sometimes difficult to notice. Our shepherd does not need to outshout the world; we just need to listen just a little better.

Our Lord wants us to learn and know the letter of the law. This is one reason we recite the Decalogue on first Sundays and sometimes other Low Masses. But the letter of the law is only the starting point, especially if you’re getting it out of the KJV or our BCP because it’s not quite in your language. Woody Guthrie had a song entitled “Philadelphia Lawyer,” where the titular character courts a cowboy’s girl – completely okay within the letter of the law, but (spoiler alert) it doesn’t end so well for the lawyer! We need to be Philadelphia Lawyers of the spirit of the Law. We have to dig deeper to understand the intent of the Law and, thus, to start to understand the intent of the One who gave it. We do not do this all on our own. We do not need a cast of detectives and DAs. We are helped by the spirit in the Law, that Divine intent that helps us understand what following the right path looks like and why it is just and to our good. It is one and the same with that still small voice that, like the calm voice on your navigation app, helps us to course correct to get to our heavenly goal despite the occasional wrong turn.

My navigation app is currently set with the voice of Warchief Thrall from World of Warcraft. When there’s police reported ahead, he sometimes says, “Police reported ahead. Law and order. Two good things when used wisely.” It’s actually quite a deep comment that they are separate things – law by itself does not create order, order by itself does not suggest laws, and that’s why the TV show (Law & Order) splits its narrative between solving the crime and working through the trial. Our interest in following the spirit of the law is that when we reach the second act of our episode and stand before that final judgment, we will not be able to get off on a technicality. I used to joke with one of my priest friends that I was going to try to plead temporary insanity. He assured me that that wouldn’t work. However, we are blessed beyond our deserving that He who shaped the universe has both justice and mercy.

So let us strive to live with righteousness, honoring the spirit of the Law given us, loving God first and loving our neighbor, that we may do our part to nurture Divine order and to live unto God, that when heaven and earth do pass, we may meet our Judge’s merciful gaze and enter His gates with thanksgiving to find our eternal welcome.